Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nikki Hunt's avatar

This is a frame I've been waiting to see articulated — health as a cross-disciplinary, energetic process rather than a purely molecular one. I'd offer one addition, from a discipline that rarely gets a seat at this table: the built environment.

You describe the mind as “the subjective interface between our inner biology and our outer environment.” But that outer environment is now largely one we construct — and some of its inputs may act on cellular energetics through pathways that don't begin with conscious perception.

Light is an intriguing example. Mitochondrial dynamics and respiration appear to be clock-controlled and aligned with the light–dark cycle (Ceccato et al., Mitochondrion, 2026), while Glen Jeffery's group at UCL has reported wavelength-dependent effects on mitochondrial function, including opposing effects of shorter blue and longer red wavelengths.

The environment isn't simply a backdrop the mind perceives. It is also a continuous source of physical and sensory information to biology.

So perhaps the frame is not only mind–body, but mind–body–space. We evolved for hundreds of thousands of years in natural environments, yet in little more than a century we have radically remade the conditions in which we spend most of our lives.

If reductionism's failure is leaving things outside the field of view, the spaces we now spend around 90% of our lives inside may be one of the largest things still outside it.

That's the bridge I spend my days on, from the design side. I'd love to see it built from yours too.

Jacek Hoffman's avatar

The essay does not yet present a mechanism, causal model, or experimental design that would distinguish these interpretations from more conventional neuroendocrine, behavioral, or psychosomatic explanations.

At this stage, such claims therefore remain speculative rather than empirically distinguished.

A better approach would be to consider the extensive placebo and nocebo literature, which has experimentally demonstrated expectation-dependent changes in physiology and symptom expression under controlled conditions.

These studies could provide a much more robust empirical basis for testing specific causal pathways between mind and body or cosmos. Or whatever.

11 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?